Martin McDonagh is in his shadow no more. For years, the great director was always sold to the public as “Irish Tarantino” or a “QT Descendant” or something condescending like that. And for years, McDonagh has tried again and again to shake the reputation, but the shadow looms. Wild Horse Nine is where I’m going to start officially fighting back against that stereotype: Tarantino could never have made this film, because McDonagh’s deliberate ground-up construction of his own career led him to direct the hell out of this wonderful picture.
It’s 1973, in Chile. CIA Agents Chris (John Malkovich) and Lee (Sam Rockwell) are taking a vacation to Easter Island for the week at the behest of local bureau chief MJ (Steve Buscemi). The pair go there to see the giant heads, flirt with young beautiful Chilean girls like Monica (Mariana di Girolamo) and Alicia (Ailin Salas), and if you’re a legendary agent like Chris, really start writing that memoir you’re talking about. Not that MJ is thrilled about that; in fact, methinks that’s why Lee accompanied Chris on this trip in the first place.
Initially I dismissed Wild Horse Nine as In Bruges but Americans. Only on the surface is it that. McDonagh’s script for this 2026 version is much more mature and assured. Each scene has the markers of McDonagh scripts: hilarious vulgarity and political incorrectness, layers and layers of jokes, fragile male contemplation, pontificating on an exotic locale, etc. He’s lost none of his penchant for dark jokes as he ages. He uses his Rapa Nui (Easter Island) locale maybe better than Bruges, having a blast with Chris and Lee cracking jokes about Moai (“the big heads”), but also using those strange statues and the relatively remote island as a place for the CIA agents to really sit in and deal with their thoughts. Pairing the aging Americans with the young Chileans is much smarter than a younger McDonagh would have done, as Monica and Alicia struggle to understand the “lessons” Chris is trying to impart on them. Most importantly, the build to the finale is wonderfully constructed. Each scene contains some little moment that upends the narrative we have been watching, enough to excite us for what’s next, but not enough where the story goes off the rails like some of his earlier efforts do. Through the specific situation we’re in, those reveals come from the characters McDonagh creates, sneakily opening the door for a deeper emotional well than you initially think you’re going to experience when John Malkovich shows up in a Rocky Balboa hat.
Speaking of Malkovich, welcome to the McDonaghverse! Sad you hadn’t come sooner. The movie at times feels like it’s there to showcase all the nuances to the great actor’s abilities. He yells here and there, but mostly this is a quieter, pensive Malkovich, game for the wordplay but ready to break your heart at the drop of that Rocky hat too. At his side is McDonagh’s trusted acolyte, Sam Rockwell. Even though he previously won an Oscar with a McDonagh character, Rockwell is I think better here for what his task is. His Lee is there to just sit and react, dropping dimes so Malkovich, Parker Posey, or others can slam dunk the jokes home. And yet, he’s never a bland time suck; the reaction shots are stellar, and his understanding of a McDonagh joke quip make his patter necessary for Malkovich to soar the way he does. Plus, when the “real sh*t” starts happening, Sam can turn on a dime with John, supporting his actor friend so we ache just a little more because of Rockwell’s work. Parker Posey and Buscemi have fun in bit parts here, but the big supporting winner is Chilean actress Mariana di Girolamo, taking what could be a fantasy part and making it much more interesting than I’m guessing what is on the page.
And that is why Martin McDonagh is QT’s little buddy no more. Wild Horse Nine is movie entertainment of the highest order, that Martin McDonagh conjures to life because of his years of making his films on his terms, getting better and better with each one. Props also for giving us one of the funniest images I never could have imagined either early on, and than completely nailing the callback when I didn’t see it coming. One of the big laughs of the year.