I get so much pleasure attempting to do Jimmy Stewart impressions. I do them so much, and so do many in Hollywood, that people forget at some point, there was a real person behind the Oscar winning It’s a Wonderful Life legend. And who better to play him than the actor who played aw shucks Archie from Riverdale?
Jimmy opens with Stewart (KJ Apa) living the Hollywood big life in 1940. He’s just won his Oscar for The Philadelphia Story, and is dating the beautiful Ginger Rogers (Jemma Donovan) while legendary gossip columnist Hedda Hopper (Sarah Drew) follows America’s beloved actor around. In a “shocking” turn, Jimmy sends his Oscar to dad (Neal McDonough) for approval…only for the stoic Indiana, Pennsylvania native to praise other boys from entering WWII to fight the Nazis. Jimmy had some flying lessons growing up, and enlists in the Air Force, to overcome his daddy issues, and whatever other character flaws he’s gotta get through before Frank Capra (Max Casella) sends him a script about George Bailey.
I’m legitimately shocked KJ Apa had this in him. I accepted he was gonna be a TV star or a supporting character in good movies maybe. But he’s excellent playing a legendary figure we all know by sound and Christmastime. He turns Stewart into a real person, getting beneath that voice and down into a straightforward but well executed character study of the man behind the movies. Apa takes the pretty bad screenplay and elevates it to something at least a little interesting, finding some particulars and complexity where I don’t think there actually was any. I hope producers get to see Apa’s work here, sans red hair, and start putting him in real parts cause he can handle it.
I just wish Jimmy had a more clear focus. The movie tries to cram in EVERYTHING that happened to Stewart during this time, to the movie’s detriment. The best stuff is Jimmy the actor becoming James the Air Force Colonel, learning how to lead men and find real conviction in his life instead of just “lies” as he calls acting a few times. The movie makes up his meeting of a woman named Julia (Kara Killmer) to add in some romance that isn’t necessary and doesn’t work, as well as a too long ending that goes for Frank Capra inception that it’s been feeding throughout annoyingly so. I’m pretty sure more time with Jimmy and his battalion replacing the lame romcom stuff would have made for a better motion picture, but perhaps the creative team realized too late what they had with Apa and his performance.
This Jimmy is also a sneaky faith based movie, but it doesn’t hit you too hard with it. I do wonder if we saw this as a descent into hell movie for Stewart, who does It’s a Wonderful Life to throw people off his scent, then goes down a dark Hitchcockian rabbit hole turning into a weird old man. I guess watching George Bailey become Potter is only fun for cynical old me? Point taken. Sorry America, you can have this Jimmy Stewart forever and ever.